- ClimateFast ClimateVoting Records Toronto

2024.IE16.8

Fossil Fuel Advocacy Advertising on City Assets

Cleaner Energy City Council consideration on Oct 9, 2024

Background

“Fossil fuel companies have a well-documented history of using their immense wealth for advocacy advertising to undermine public support for policies that reduce fossil fuel pollution. Such policies are necessary and urgent to preserve a liveable future for today’s young people. The Pathways Alliance, a coalition of six billionaire fossil fuel companies who produce 95% of tar sands bitumen, has actively advertised for this purpose in Toronto, eliciting a number of public complaints. Another fossil fuel lobby group, Canada Action, has also actively advertised across Canada.”

Source: City of Toronto

Item Description

This item proposes for a “report back by the second quarter of 2025 on a policy to decline fossil fuel advocacy advertising on City assets”.

Source: City of Toronto

Proposed by

Councillor Dianne Saxe

Result

Carried
Yes15 No6 Absent4

Votes

Yes
Photo of Paul Ainslie
Councillor
Paul Ainslie
Ward 24, Scarborough-Guildwood
Scarborough Community
Absent
Photo of Brad Bradford
Councillor
Brad Bradford
Ward 19, Beaches-East York
Toronto and East York Community
Yes
Photo of Alejandra Bravo
Councillor
Alejandra Bravo
Ward 9, Davenport
Toronto and East York Community
No
Photo of Jon Burnside
Councillor
Jon Burnside
Ward 16, Don Valley East
North York Community
Yes
Photo of Shelley Carroll
Councillor
Shelley Carroll
Ward 17, Don Valley North
North York Community
Absent
Photo of Lily Cheng
Councillor
Lily Cheng
Ward 18, Willowdale
North York Community
Yes
Photo of Olivia Chow
Mayor
Olivia Chow
No
Photo of Mike Colle
Councillor
Mike Colle
Ward 8, Eglinton-Lawrence
North York Community
Yes
Photo of Vincent Crisanti
Councillor
Vincent Crisanti
Ward 1, Etobicoke North
Etobicoke York Community
Yes
Photo of Paula Fletcher
Councillor
Paula Fletcher
Ward 14, Toronto-Danforth
Toronto and East York Community
No
Photo of Stephen Holyday
Councillor
Stephen Holyday
Ward 2, Etobicoke Centre
Etobicoke York Community
Yes
Photo of Parthi Kandavel
Councillor
Parthi Kandavel
Ward 20, Scarborough Southwest
Scarborough Community
Yes
Photo of Ausma Malik
Councillor
Ausma Malik
Ward 10, Spadina-Fort York
Toronto and East York Community
No
Photo of Nick Mantas
Councillor
Nick Mantas
Ward 22, Scarborough-Agincourt
Scarborough Community
Yes
Photo of Josh Matlow
Councillor
Josh Matlow
Ward 12, Toronto-St. Paul's
Toronto and East York Community
Yes
Photo of Jennifer McKelvie
Councillor
Jennifer McKelvie
Ward 25, Scarborough-Rouge Park
Scarborough Community
Yes
Photo of Chris Moise
Councillor
Chris Moise
Ward 13, Toronto Centre
Toronto and East York Community
Yes
Photo of Amber Morley
Councillor
Amber Morley
Ward 3, Etobicoke-Lakeshore
Etobicoke York Community
Absent
Photo of Jamaal Myers
Councillor
Jamaal Myers
Ward 23, Scarborough North
Scarborough Community
No
Photo of Frances Nunziata
Councillor
Frances Nunziata
Ward 5, York South-Weston
Etobicoke York Community
No
Photo of James Pasternak
Councillor
James Pasternak
Ward 6, York Centre
North York Community
Yes
Photo of Gord Perks
Councillor
Gord Perks
Ward 4, Parkdale-High Park
Toronto and East York Community
Yes
Photo of Anthony Perruzza
Councillor
Anthony Perruzza
Ward 7, Humber River-Black Creek
North York Community
Yes
Photo of Dianne Saxe
Councillor
Dianne Saxe
Ward 11, University-Rosedale
Toronto and East York Community
Absent
Photo of Michael Thompson
Councillor
Michael Thompson
Ward 21, Scarborough Centre
Scarborough Community

Additional Details

An amendment proposed by Dianne Saxe on July 24, 2025 added a requirement for a “report back to the Infrastructure and Environment Committee by the first quarter of 2027 on complaints received by the City about alleged greenwashing in advertisements carried on City assets, and what, if any, measures have been taken in response by the Competition Bureau of Canada.” Part 2 of this motion, advocating for an investigation into the necessity and feasibility of prohibiting fossil fuel advertisements altogether was overwhelmingly rejected, having only the support of Dianne Saxe and Jamaal Myers. Brad Bradford, Olivia Chow, Amber Morley, and Michael Thompson were absent for both parts of the amendment vote.